When it comes to buying a home, there is a big decision to make: should you buy an older house or go with new construction? Both options have advantages and disadvantages, and it’s important to weigh them both carefully before deciding. An older house may come with more charm and character. However, a new home can offer more modern amenities, energy efficiency, and a lower maintenance cost. Additionally, both types of homes may come with hidden fees, such as needing repairs or renovations. Ultimately, buying an old house or new construction should be based on the buyer’s circumstances and preferences. So, an old house vs. new construction: which option is right for you? Here are some points to consider.
An older home’s pro is a newer home’s con
1. Charm & Character
No doubt, older homes possess a unique charm and character that modern structures simply cannot replicate. After all, these homes have had years to build up their personality - usually 75 to 100+ years. Often, older homes show off distinct architecture and craftsmanship that you won't find in a newer build. For instance, high ceilings, detailed crown moldings, stained-glass windows, quaint door knobs, arched doorways, antique chandeliers, etc. You get the picture. When have you seen these in today's residences?
Modern neighborhoods often have a uniform look, with rows of houses that look nearly identical. And recreating the features in a new construction home would require shelling out a small fortune.
2. Lot Size
While contemplating what’s better for you, old build vs. new build, you might want to compare lot sizes of both options in your real estate market. Of course, the case varies from one geographical area to the next. However, you might find that older homes may offer more land value in comparison to newer builds. This is due to the fact that in the past, the land was more plentiful and, therefore, cheaper.
In recent years, however, the amount of undeveloped land has decreased. So, developers have been forced to create, or maybe it’s better to say “squeeze” homes on much smaller lots. Therefore, you’ll have less space outdoors than in an older home and less opportunity to boost your curb and screen appeal when it comes time to put your home on the market.
3. Location
Moreover, older builds tend to be located in established communities and neighborhoods. Since the land was much more affordable in the past, they also benefited from bigger yards. This means more room for outdoor activities, entertainment for your kids, and landscaping projects. Another advantage of owning an old house is its proximity to a city or town center. Many towns and cities were originally built around a central hub of commerce and industry, and these areas remain the city’s most vibrant and desirable parts. Old houses are often located in these city centers, providing close access to parks, schools, restaurants, and other local amenities. Living in a neighborhood like this allows people to be part of the action and experience all their town or city offers.
With newer homes, it’s a whole different story. As space becomes increasingly scarce, it is becoming more difficult for builders to construct new homes near amenities like pools, gyms, grocery stores, and properties with plenty of yard space.
4. Cost
Generally, an old house is more affordable than a new construction home. This means you can get more house for your money and pay a lower cost upfront for an older home. Moreover, if an old house is listed on a national, state, or local registry, buyers may benefit from financial incentives when buying and renovating such a property. Despite the potential renovations required, the lower purchase price of an older house may give buyers a larger budget for improvements.
New builds will have a higher upfront cost. Plus, there is a greater demand for new builds. Thus, you and your agent are likely to have less room to negotiate a deal. The final price can be pretty high. When you calculate and add the relocation costs, especially for long-distance moving, buying a new home might break the bank. Of course, it helps to know your budget in advance since you can organize it better that way.
A newer home’s pro is an older home’s con
1. Maintenance
New construction homes require less maintenance and upkeep than older homes. Tested building materials and practices, up-to-date systems, and new appliances, new construction guarantees that you’ll be worry-free for many years. So, suppose you’re looking for fewer hassles or have little to no money in reserve for emergency repairs, unexpected costs, significant renovations, or replacements. In that case, new construction may be the way to go.
Older houses may be more affordable upfront. However, they come with an inevitable need for replacements, repairs, and upgrades. So, the cost of maintenance is one of their greatest drawbacks. The buildings were constructed with outdated materials. Therefore, the costs of fixing, replacing, or maintaining plumbing and HVAC units can become expensive over a few years. Plus, it can be challenging to locate the parts you’d need.
2. Efficiency
When it comes to your old house vs. new construction decision in terms of efficiency, new-construction homes are much more energy-efficient. So, you can expect to save more money on your utility bills in the long term, thanks to modern building techniques, the materials used, and the appliances installed.
As for older homes, owners always complained about them being too hot in the summer and too cold in the winter. In fact, the experts from movingworldwide.com reported this as one of the main reasons they’ve decided to move to a newer building. The owners said it doesn’t matter how high they crank their furnace or AC. The main culprits? Old drafty windows and poor insulation. So, besides cold toes, you can expect high hydro bills as your AC and furnace suck up more energy to cool and heat your abode.
3. Warranty
Most new construction homes come with a builder’s warranty, which provides peace of mind. The length of the warranty can vary depending on the builder. Typically, however, it covers structural defects, major mechanical systems, and other major components for a period of one to two years.
Few things are worse than moving into a new space and suddenly noticing all the quirks you missed in the showings. Perhaps the roof has deteriorated and needs replacing, or the HVAC systems are older than you thought. And unfortunately, that’s what you can expect when buying an older home. Homeowners should purchase a home warranty through a third-party provider to cover any potential repairs or maintenance needed in an older home.
4. Design
Finally, when it comes to older homes versus new construction in terms of design and layout, a new home allows you more control and freedom. So, maybe you were hoping for a few luxuries… Maybe a six-burner gas stove, marble kitchen countertops, sprinkler systems, larger rooms, an enormous bathtub, etc. With newer homes, you can quickly check these and similar features off your wish list. They’re easily customizable to suit your style preferences, lifestyle, and needs.
Pre-owned homes might not have some of the features you’re looking for. Adding them to a property with a pre-existing design and layout might get pretty expensive.
Old House vs. New Construction: Bottom Line
Ultimately, deciding which type of house is right for you is a personal decision that should carefully consider your needs and lifestyle. Old houses have their own unique charm, as well as the potential for customization and upgrades. New construction provides the opportunity to build a home tailored to your specifications. Regardless of your choice, both can provide a great living space and a place to call home. So, old house vs. new construction: which would you say is the right fit for you?
Comments